May 2007 - Comments after the first winter under the cover: Our boat faced west and was only 20 yards from the beach and completely exposed high above the sand dunes. The cover and frame withstood very strong winds and direct exposure to the NW - NE angle from which Lake Superior's strongest winter gales blow. Working under the cover this spring was easy and warm out of the wind.
The cover shows visible chafing in a few areas which we will have to reinforce. Our biggest issue is that we had chafing along our rub strake because the slightly prominent oval-head screws that fasten the S/S edging caused dime-sized chafing spots over each one (every 6 inches). An option would have been to cover the rub strake with something to protect the cover - maybe a piece of split foam used for insulating plumbing or even some tape. We thought that Fairclough should have been aware of the likelihood of this and sewn in chafing strips accordingly.
June 2007 Fairclough offered to sew on the rub strake chafe strips and take care any other visible chafing areas for $250 - reasonable.
August 2007 We decided to ship the cover back to Fairclough to have the above work done. They finished the job quickly and freight was included in their quote. They did a good job and also added chafe patches and strips to other areas that showed signs of chafe from last season. We wish rub strake chafing strips would have been sewn on initially to avoid extra handling but this was a good solution. According to Fairclough the prominent screws fastening our s/s rub strake edging are not common to every CR34 so the problem was not foreseen.
October 2007 The cover went on in half the time this year. The wind was light and having one season's experience, it was easy. If I had a helper, I could have cut the time in half again. This year I fitted foam pipe insulation strips over our rub strake for added chafe protection. Since the cover appears to shrink when wet, it is important to lace the ends shut when the cover is dry. As I found out when I loosened the aft lacing, the cover was impossible to lace completely closed after the rain came down for several hours and tightened everything up. I am very satisfied with the cover. My only regret (my own fault) is that we did not spring for a second door to open up more air-flow on hot days when I work under the cover.
November 2007 This month we heard from an acquaintance that they were unhappy with Fairclough's service. They ordered a cover and discussed all the issues with the sales staff, being careful to mention several times their special needs, including provisions for gallows and davits. Faircluogh promised that everything would be easy and said "we do this all the time". Fairclough even came and took measurements and assembled the frame in preparation. But when it came time to complete the job, Fairclough was unwilling to perform the extra work they promised and the job ended. It was too late in the season to contract with another company. I know stories like this have two sides - this is only the side of the customer. But customers are what make a company viable and it seems there could have been a better solution.
Spring 2008 The cover did well again, except for a small area of chafing through a chafing protection strip which we will have to address next fall. Winter winds were nasty this past year.
Helpful Hint passed on from our friend Dennis: Store the cover (dry) in a large covered garbage can(s) to keep the critters out.
Oct 2008 The cover went on in about three hours thanks to the help from my son. This is one case where the whole is much greater than the sum of its parts.
May 2014 We are going into our ninth season - eight winters on the cover and it is holding up just fine. It was a great choice for many reasons. I will reiterate that I wish I had installed a door on both sides for convenience, visibility, and for cross ventilation on occasional hot days.
Sept 2014 While pulling "too hard" trying to fit the cover, I ripped out an 18" section of seam near the bow in a critical spot - no time for professional help so I sewed it closed it by hand. It's nearly 10 years old - go figure - I suppose the thread is beginning to weaken from the winter torture. I'm pretty certain it still has a long way to go before it self destructs but some seams may need attention soon.
Oct 2016 We had all cover seams restitched over the summer. We are aiming for no more rips. The sun, even way up here in the north, really does a number on the threads, both on the cover and boat canvas in general.
Cigano Home | Photos | Specs | Decision | Evaluation | Gear & Maint | About Cabo | Research Threads